Dear Senator Warren,
The FTX melee has infused crypto regulation efforts with new life. Politicians pounced at the opportunity, including you. The bill you’ve recently introduced requires the U.S. Treasury Secretary to create a rule disallowing financial institutions from transacting with self-custody wallets, citing the FTX debacle. It was a wholly inappropriate response to the failure of a centralized entity already regulated by a government. Your shotgun approach to regulation is dangerous to innovation in the United States, and particularly Main Street.
Thankfully, some U.S. lawmakers understand not only crypto but also the foundation of freedom upon which the United States was founded. Representative Warren Davidson (R-OH) knew it was only a matter of time before someone like you would try to compel the Treasury Department to interfere with consumers’ right to self-custody of their digital assets — as Rep. Davidson puts it, “to own and possess private property.” Therefore, he introduced last February the Keep Your Coins Act, designed to preserve Americans’ right to privacy in transacting with crypto assets.
The bill would prohibit any federal agency from implementing a rule that would impair a person’s ability to act as a self-custodian, and thus their ability to conduct peer-to-peer transactions without the need for a third-party intermediary, such as FTX.
“As the federal government seeks more regulation of the crypto ecosystem, it seeks to impose more surveillance over American citizens,” stated Rep. Davidson after introducing the bill. “It’s vital that we preserve the attributes of cash transactions by protecting the permissionless nature of cash. No third party should be required for two people (or companies) to use money as a means of exchange, store of value, and record of account. This bill ensures that individuals will always have the ability to transact without any intermediaries.”
The FTX collapse makes it obvious why self-custody should be protected. Sam Bankman-Fried convinced people to send their digital assets to FTX by positioning the company as a massive financial institution with lavish sponsorships and spokespersons. The illusion Bankman-Fried cultivated around FTX fostered trust. Blockchains, in the vision of Bitcoin creator Satoshi Nakamoto, are trustless.
Bankman-Fried took customers’ digital assets at FTX and put them under the control of Alameda Research, the hedge fund he founded that was the trading arm of FTX. He created FTT, FTX’s native token, to use as collateral on loans from FTX to Alameda. He leveraged Alameda’s assets to irresponsible levels. Bankman-Fried’s actions are the same old criminality seen over and over again in traditional finance, and they were made possible because people sent him their money to act as a third-party intermediary. To then submit a bill in the aftermath regulating self-custody makes little logical sense.
FTX customers who transferred their digital assets from FTX into their own self-custody wallets did not lose money to Bankman-Fried’s fraud. You want to strip consumers of the only sound protection against the failure of any third-party intermediary.
FTX is the exact opposite of Nakamoto’s blockchain and original conception of cryptocurrency. “Commerce on the Internet has come to rely almost exclusively on financial institutions serving as trusted third parties to process electronic payments,” reads the opening lines of the white paper authored by Bitcoin’s pseudonymous inventor. “While the system works well enough for most transactions, it still suffers from the inherent weaknesses of the trust-based model.” Bankman-Fried exploited the flaws in the traditional financial system, not blockchain.
You also argued another appropriate response to the FTX collapse would be, ultimately, for the government to stop people from owning Bitcoin in their retirement accounts. In a letter to Fidelity Investments, you and two of your fellow Senate Democrats — Sens. Dick Durbin (D-Ill.) and Tina Smith (D-Minn.) — argued for a moratorium on people having the choice to allocate Bitcoins into their retirement accounts.
Fidelity, which only recently allowed customers to allocate part of their contributions to Bitcoin, isn’t forcing anyone to put retirement funds into bitcoin. Rather, it’s merely giving them the choice to add Bitcoin exposure alongside their stocks, bonds, precious metals, index funds, emerging markets, and other sometimes risky and volatile investments. Choice. That’s what Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies are all about. Preventing people from owning Bitcoin in their retirement funds won’t stop a future FTX.
During the 2008 financial crisis, you were viewed as a champion of the people against the banking system, against the Wells Fargos, against the Chases, against the HSBCs of the world. Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies are a solution to the banking oligopolies’ predatory ways. It’s one way for people to exit the banking system, take custody of their own money, and not worry about fees and banks taking advantage of them.
Your open hostility towards financial freedom goes against American values while also disempowering consumers, leaving them at the mercy of the financial fraudsters you purport to fight. A more constitutional approach would presumably foster innovation. The U.S. state of Wyoming has gained notoriety worldwide for promulgating measured blockchain legislation. Perhaps the rest of America — as well as regulators elsewhere in the world, including Europe and Asia — could learn from the so-called “Cowboy State.”
Sincerely,
Kadan Stadelmann
More important than explaining the rules of curbside composting is getting L.A. residents on board in the first place.
Investigators are looking into Snapchat’s alleged role in fentanyl-laced pills being distributed through the popular video and messaging app. Bloomberg is reporting that the FBI and Justice Department’s investigation is part of a broader probe into the nation’s counterfeit drug problem.
Among the leaders in terms of year-to-date gains thus far are Cardano (CRYPTO: ADA), Polkadot (CRYPTO: DOT), and The Sandbox (CRYPTO: SAND), which have surged by roughly 50% or more in just a few weeks. As is the case with most recent rallies, the moods of equity investors and those focused on digital assets appear to be closely aligned. Polkadot has seen strong developer interest to kick off 2023, becoming the leading blockchain in terms of development activity over the past month, according to crypto market intelligence platform Santiment.
Why dive right into the deep and complicated end of the crypto market? These three popular and well-known cryptocurrencies are easy to use and understand.
A 20-year-old man is in custody after police found $67,000 in cash and 13 pounds of marijuana inside his home on Wooldridge Road.
The research says that a large number of companies based in the European Union and G-7 nations are still operating in Russia.
Yes, the Broncos hired Vance Joseph over Kyle Shanahan in 2017. No, we'll never get over it.
House Bill 101, would have required that all New Hampshire voters register for a political party four months before the September state primaries.
Jamahal Hill praises UFC legend Glover Teixeira after sending him off into retirement following his title victory.
Fox NewsA day after M&M’s canceled their “spokescandies” amid pushback from Fox News hosts who no longer found them sexy, the conservative cable giant found its latest target for outrage: “woke” video game consoles with power-saving features.Earlier this month, Microsoft announced that Xbox would offer “carbon aware game downloads and updates” as part of the company’s ongoing effort to reduce carbon emissions and help combat climate change.“For example, instead of your Xbox waking up during the
The discovery of classified documents at former Vice President Mike Pence’s home is complicating efforts by congressional Republicans to coordinate their lines of attack on President Biden’s handling of similar materials from his time as second-in-command. Pence’s team disclosed Tuesday that his attorneys conducted a search of his Indiana home out of an abundance of…
Republicans last year successfully repealed the military's COVID-19 vaccine mandate despite the Pentagon's support for the requirement.
Republicans don't want fiscal responsibility; they want to destroy the government's ability to improve the lives of American citizens
Elon Musk and Tesla have set a goal to produce 20 million electric vehicles by 2030. The Austin, Texas-based EV manufacturer has some work to do to reach that goal as it produced a record 1.37 million EVs in 2022. Tesla's Austin and Fremont, Calif., assembly plants currently have the combined production capacity of 900,000.
Vice President Kamala Harris joined in what has become a nightly ritual in Monterey Park as hundreds gathered in front of a dance studio where 11 people were killed.
The Yellowstone spinoff, 1923 just aired in December and is already taking a month-long break. Here's when you can catch new episodes of the show in 2023.
A key technical indicator has just flashed that Bitcoin is in the early stages of a new bull market. But some bearish signs remain for cryptocurrencies.
Atlanta, Baltimore and Detroit all have two things in common: Democrat governments and the highest per capita murder rates, according to this WalletHub study.
The Broncos terminated the expiring contract of interim coach and special assistant Jerry Rosburg, but that doesn’t mean Rosburg is done in Denver. Ian Rapoport of NFL Media reports that it was a procedural move. “My understanding is he’s well regarded and may be back with Denver with new leadership,” Rapoport wrote on Twitter. The [more]
General economic woes last year crushed many of the world's most promising cryptocurrencies. That's because, in times of uncertainty, investors tend to favor the safest investments. Cryptocurrency is pretty new, and it's too early to know exactly how big its role will be in areas like finance and entertainment a few years from now.
Author
Administraroot
